Home » Leadership » Is Your Team Made Up of Rockstars or Superstars?

Is Your Team Made Up of Rockstars or Superstars?

Reading Time: 3 minutes

I love the distinction that Kim Scott makes in her book ‘Radical Candor‘ [non-affiliate link] between rockstars and superstars. And I think it has huge implications for how we lead, manage, and shape teams in our workplaces.

Rockstars vs Superstars - the definitions

🌟 Rockstar: a solid, stable performer on a gradual growth trajectory, or perhaps content exactly where they are. They provide a steady foundation for the team.

🌟 Superstar: a change agent ready for rapid growth. They’re hungry for new opportunities and making change. They push the team to keep moving forward.

So which are better - rockstars or superstars?

The case for rockstars

For decades, businesses have thrived thanks to their rockstars – steady, dependable performers, who show up and get their work done. They’re reliable and conscientious. You know exactly what to expect when you work with them. And they’re usually really easy to manage!

But, when you face uncertainty or need to change the way things are done, rockstars sometimes struggle to make the necessary leap into the unknown.

The case for superstars

If you listen to the way some people talk these days, then you’d think that a team of superstars is the ideal. After all, they’re hungry for growth, they’re pushing their limits, and they’re reaching for the stars. They drive innovation through their insatiable curiosity. They’re ready to move fast and break things, as the famous (or infamous) Silicon Valley saying goes. Sounds great! Or does it?

Too many superstars in a team can create instability and result in scattered efforts, as they each chase the ‘next big thing’ and forget (or neglect) to do the boring stuff that is required to keep an organisation functioning.

The best team is a blended team

In almost every organisation, you’re more likely to see more sustainable success in a team with a mix of rockstars and superstars.

It’s a yin yang thing – instead of a bunch of superstars falling flat on their face because they’re going too fast, the rockstars help make the pace sustainable. And instead of a bunch of rockstars getting stuck in old ways, superstars help everyone to embrace the necessary changes.

Leading and managing rockstars and superstars

Now, a blended team isn’t always easy to lead and manage. That’s because you’ve got people who want different things and respond to different leadership and management styles and incentives. You’ll need to grow as a leader to help your team do their best work.

Growing your leadership capability doesn’t have to be hard, and you don’t have to try to figure everything out on your own. Why not start by asking your people for their “user guide”? That is, how they prefer to work, what kind of communication works best with them, what incentives drive them, how they like to receive feedback, etc.

Then, start to shape the way you lead and manage your team with their user guides in mind. You won’t please everyone all of the time, but when you’re consistently making a sincere effort, your team will see that, and will want to help you improve.

So, what kind of stars do you have in your team? What kind of star are you? And how can you help each kind of star to shine brighter?

Leadership development

I love working with leaders to help them grow their capabilities and hone their skills and strengths. If you’d like to know more, check out my Coaching and Training pages, or hit the button to book your free, no-obligation 30-minute call.

More reading

In addition to Radical Candor, I highly recommend Liz Wiseman’s book ‘Impact Players‘, which covers a different but overlapping approach.

For more on personal user guides, I recommend this post: A personal user manual for working with me

Comments

Still image from a webinar, showing a dark-haired woman wearing a black top and purple cardigan sitting in front of several bookshelves. She is smiling and about to say something.

Watch now: Personal strengths masterclass

Reading Time: < 1 minute Are you ready for a masterclass in personal strengths? Listen in on this conversation between me, Christopher Miller and Paul Fawcett as we talk about what personal strengths are, and why they matter so much

Read More »

What are your obstacles telling you?

Reading Time: < 1 minute You’ve heard all of the cliches about how “obstacles are the way”. Or that they are “the frightening things we see when we take our eyes off the goal”. Nice platitudes, but not all that

Read More »
Text-based image. There are three coloured geometric shapes around the outside. In the centre in bold text is the quotation "We can do hard things" and underneath is the quote source, Glennon Doyle. At the bottom centre of the image is the Daria Williamson logo, with the words 'Coach ~ Facilitator ~ Trainer' and the URL dariawilliamson.com

My mantra when life gets hard

Reading Time: 2 minutes The old saying “When life gives you lemons, make lemonade” gets trotted out all too often when someone is going through a hard time. I don’t think it’s particularly useful. It’s trite and can come

Read More »
Scroll to Top